[sticky entry] Sticky: Welcome to D4D!

Welcome! Please join us for the inaugural round of Doodle 4 Doodle. D4D is a low-pressure art exchange that is hosted on Archive of Our Own. Submit a doodle and receive a doodle from your assigned creator. This exchange is open to participants who are 18+, of any skill level, and of any drawing or painting style. Seasoned artists, art novices, and everyone in between are welcome to join. Let's make some art!


✩°。 ⋆  ( . . * . . )  ⋆。°✩


In D4D, you can request characters, pairings, settings, and objects. In return, you will match to someone and make them a doodle that adheres to our minimum requirements.

This exchange is based on Multifandom Doodle. If you're familiar with Multifandom Doodle, you may want to read this post that highlights the small changes that D4D has made for this event!

[sticky entry] Sticky: Doodle 4 Doodle: Rules Post

The Basics

You must be 18+ to participate.

By signing up for this exchange, you are committing to create a gift of art for at least one person and receive a gift of art in return. All assignments created for this event need to fulfill one tag from your recipient's request while respecting their DNWs.

The minimum requirement for assignments is
  • a doodle or clean sketch
    • of at least 400x400 pixels
    • on an single color background or unlined paper
    • that contains some element of drawing and/or painting
    • that you have made yourself

Artwork that exceeds the minimum requirement (portraits, comics, paintings, mixed media and more) are welcome!

Please note: your doodle should be scanned or photographed if you are drawing traditionally. Scans/photographs should be in focus and clearly lit. 


More on Art Requirements )
Nominations )
Signing Up )
Do Not Wants )
Matching )
Assignments and Posting )
Defaulting )
Pinch Hits )
Treats )
Emergency Pinch Hits )
Other Considerations )

Questions or Concerns?

If you have any questions, concerns, or comments, please comment on the screened mod contact post or email the nod at outstandingfroggie2 at proton dot me. I will respond ASAP.

If you'd like to chat, you can also discuss the event on the BFE Art Discord!


Next Round coming in April!

Thank you to everyone who wrote in with their thoughts about what kinds of art events they'd like to see in 2026! The overwhelming response was another round of Doodle for Doodle with more-or-less the same rules as it was run during the first round.

The next round of Doodle 4 Doodle is set to begin nominations in mid-April. The event schedule should go up by the end of this month. I hope to see you all there! <3

Creators Revealed! + feedback about next event

Creators are now revealed, and that brings Doodle 4 Doodle to a close for 2025. The collection is now unmoderated, and will remain open for any late treats anyone may want to post.

To all of our participants: thank you for your interest and support!! From those who nominated, to those who doodled, and those who pinch hit: we couldn't have done this without you. I hope everyone has had a lovely Doodle 4 Doodle. <3 I personally have had a blast running this exchange, and I suspect I'll be browsing through the collection for the next couple of weeks.

If you have any feedback based on this round, please feel free to contact me through the screened mod contact post or email me.

Looking Ahead to Spring

Before I close this round of the event, I would like to ask the Doodle 4 Doodle community if you would be interested in a doodle or art exchange during spring 2026. If you are interested in participating in an art exchange in spring, which idea would you be most interested in?
  • an art exchange, with a minimum set at something higher than a doodle and a longer creation period to accomodate the higher minimum.
  • M or E rated art exchange, with a minimum set at something higher than a doodle and with optional freeforms that act as suggestions/prompts about what to draw (e.g. no freeform matching). A longer creation period to accomodate the higher minimum.
  • M or E rated doodle exchange, with a doodle minimum and with optional freeforms that act as suggestions/prompts. (e.g. no freeform matching). Would run in basically the same timeframe as D4D, but with more time for nominations before signups begin.
  • Another round of Doodle 4 Doodle with more or less the same rules. Would run in basically the same timeframe as D4D, but there would be more time for nominations before signups begin.

Tentative start date would be in the middle of March or the middle of April. I may lean towards one month or another depending on people's feedback about when they're available.

So that's what I'm currently thinking; I'd love to hear your thoughts!!


Works Revealed!

Hello Doodlers!! Works have now been revealed for Doodle4Doodle 2025!

If there are any questions or concerns, please reach out on the screened contact post, or email outstandingfroggie2@proton.me.

Thank you all for participating with us this year!! Happy reveals!


All assignments are in!

All assignments and pinch hits are in!! Reveals are currently set to happen on schedule, on Friday December 12th @ 10pm PST (countdown to reveals).

If you would like to use this remaining time to treat:

Good luck, and I'll see you at reveals!!

Deadline passed + 2 post-deadline pinch hits

Hello doodlers! The assignment submission deadline for Doodle 4 Doodle 2025 has now passed. Several participants are still working on extensions; if you have an extension please refer back to our email or comment chain for your new assignment due date!

There are 2 new post-deadline pinch hits listed below!

To claim a pinch hit:

  • please comment below with your AO3 name and the pinch hit number & name you want to claim
  • (Optional) Tell me if you are swapping the pinch hit for your current assignment
  • (Optional) After your pinch hit is confirmed, if you aren't already signed up for the event, please feel free to leave a request on the pinch hitter's post. We'd love to make you a treat!
  • Note: All comments on this post are screened!

Post-Deadline Pinch Hits

These pinch hits are due on December 9, 10:00 PM PST (countdown).
  • PH #13 - CLAIMED
  • PH #14 - CLAIMED

New Pinch Hits 11 & 12!

We have 2 new pinch hits! Below is a list of participants who need creators, a list of their fandoms, and a link to the ao3 app with their request details. To claim a pinch hit:

  • please comment below with your AO3 name and the pinch hit number & name you want to claim
  • (Optional) Tell me if you are swapping the pinch hit for your current assignment.
  • (Optional) After your pinch hit is confirmed, if you aren't already signed up for the event, please feel free to leave a request on the pinch hitter's post. We'd love to make you a treat!
  • Note: All comments on this post are screened!
  • These pinch hits are due AFTER the assignment due date, on December 7, 10:00 PM PST (countdown).

    Pinch Hits

    • PH #11 - CLAIMED
    • PH #12 - CLAIMED

One week to deadline! + How to request an extension if you need one

Hello everyone!! I hope you're having an enjoyable time with your doodles!

The deadline is approaching; works are due in a little over one week on Sunday, November 30 at 10 PM PST. Depending on your time zone, this may be on Monday for you--you can check how much remaining time you have on the countdown timer.

Be sure to submit your doodle to the Doodle 4 Doodle collection, request an extension, or default using the default button by the deadline!

Extension Requests

  • All works (including all assignments and all pinch hits) are currently due on November 30.
  • All extension requests will be granted!
  • Be sure to request an extension before the deadline (countdown timer).
  • You may request an extension with a new due date of 10pm PST on December 6th, or 10pm PST on December 7th.
  • If you need to request an extension, please get in touch on the screened mod post or by email!

Remember to check your work

Please check your assignment before work reveals to make sure your embed links are working and your images are visible. Sometimes there are issues with image hosts disabling embeds/changing links to expire after a short period of time. This is especially true if you hosted your doodle on Discord.

I will be checking all assignments after the deadline to make sure images are visible & embedded on ao3. I will attempt to catch any broken links at that time, but I may not catch everything, so be sure to double-check your works!

Collection Opening

As a reminder: the collection opening will be delayed if every participant does not have a gift. Any participants who were defaulted on and have no gifts will be posted as post-deadline pinch hits after the assignment deadline next week.

We also currently have a pinch hitter request up! Please check those out!!

If you have any questions or comments about your assignments, or you need to request an extension, you can contact me on the screened mod post or email me at outstandingfroggie2@proton.me. Good luck!!

Pinch Hitter's Post

Pinch hitters work hard to help us with our exchange. Doodle 4 Doodle wouldn't be possible without them! Any pinch hitters who are interested in receiving treats are encouraged to post here with requests, so that interested participants can consider making treats! (If you're considering being a pinch hitter, why not take a look at Doodle 4 Doodle's current pinch hits?)


Pinch Hitter Requests


Who is eligible to make a request

  • You have picked up a pinch hit!
  • You are not already signed up to the exchange under another username.
  • You would like the chance to get treats!

How to Make a Request

Post your requests as a reply to this post! If you want to split your fandom requests into separate comments, please reply to yourself after your first post to keep things tidy.

Please don't remove or significantly change the fandom or tag part of requests after you post them unless you are adding additional requests/tags! If you need to withdraw a fandom from this post, contact me on the screened mod contact post or email me so I'm in the loop about significant changes.

Each request should include the following:


Link to Tagset

Instructions for Filling PHer Requests

Pinch hitter treats should follow all Doodle 4 Doodle assignment/treat requirements. Gifts to pinch hitters should:

  • Fulfill a fandom/tag combo & respect their DNWs
  • Be of any pixel dimension/size (400x400 pixels is the minimum for assignments. There is no minimum size for treats!)
  • Be any medium that involves drawing or painting
  • Can additionally be any other mediums that are eligible for treats (including vids, manips, graphic design/layout, collages, voxel/3D art that doesn't include additional drawn or painted elements)
If you need to brush up on how to post to the collection without an AO3 assignment

Post to the collection without an AO3 assignment

Post directly to the collection by going to the profile (https://archiveofourown.org/collections/Doodle_4_Doodle_2025/profile), clicking 'Post to Collection', and manually adding your recipient on the 'Gift this work to' line.

Where to find art hosts

Posting Artwork

AO3 does not currently host artwork. Art should be hosted on an image server that allows embeds and is broadly viewable by people on AO3. You can read more about art hosting here: Jamez’ Guide to Art Hosting for Exchanges.


Initial Pinch Hits: 6 + New PH 9

We have 1 initial pinch hit and one additional new pinch hit, which are requests that came out of the matching process without artists. Below is a list of participants who need creators, a list of their fandoms, and a link to the ao3 app with their request details. To claim a pinch hit:

  • please comment below with your AO3 name and the pinch hit number & name you want to claim
  • (Optional) Tell me if you are swapping the pinch hit for your current assignment.
  • All comments on this post are screened

These pinch hits are due on the normal assignment due date of November 30, 10:00 PM PST (countdown).

Pinch Hits

  • IPH #6 - CLAIMED
  • PH #9 - CLAIMED
  • PH #10 - CLAIMED

Assignments have been sent!

Assignments for Doodle 4 Doodle 2025 have been sent!! Please comment on this post or the screened mod post if...
  • You can't find your assignment in your AO3 Assignments page
  • You were assigned a fandom/character/ship you didn't actually offer. (Do please check to see if you matched on Creator's Choice of Doodle or Recipients OCs, though!)
  • There are any other questions about your assignment, or questions for your recipient.
Your assignment is due on November 30, 10:00 PM PST. (countdown to when assignments are due)

Assignments!

If you'd like a refresher on the minimum requirements for the exchange, or how defaulting in D4D works, please see these sections below! Very briefly:


As I mentioned in the previous post, after I ran matching, everyone was matchable on offers! However, some recipients did not have a potential giver. Those recipients will be going out as initial pinch hits. That post will be up shortly!


Signups Closed, Assignments Out Soon!

Signups for Doodle 4 Doodle 2025 are now closed! I am excited for everyone who's going to doodle with us this round!

Matching Update

There are no outstanding signup related questions or issues! Everyone made themselves matchable before the deadline, and therefore no one will be getting a random Creator's Choice of Doodle assignment.

This makes assignments rather easy! AO3 and airtable willing, assignments should be sent out within the next day or so--and definitely no later than October 30th. Initial pinch hits will be posted shortly afterwards.

If there are any questions or concerns about signups please give me a shout in the next 24 hours! If you forgot a letter link, or you forgot to add your DNWs, you can email me at outstandingfroggie2 at proton dot me or contact me on the screened mod post and I can get them added for you before assignments go out.

Nominations have closed! 48 hours left to sign up!

Nominations for the 2025 round of Doodle 4 Doodle have closed. Big thanks to everyone who nominated!! You can see the full tagset here.

Signups continue through the weekend! There are 48 hours left to sign up for this round of Doodle 4 Doodle. (countdown until signups close).

On Matching

During this last little bit of signups, you may want to check the signup summary or the ao3 app to see if you're matchable (e.g. have someone who is requesting a tag that you are offering). In this exchange, participants that aren't matchable will not be contacted after the deadline. Instead, any participant who is unmatchable after signups close will be matched at random to someone requesting Creator's Choice of Doodle.

I have done a little last minute cleanup of the tagset and approvals of the last few tags that were nominated before the tagset closed. If you have any questions about nominations/tags, or questions about matching, please feel free to leave them here or on the screened mod contact post.

24 hours left to nominate!

There's 24 hours left before the tagset closes for nominations! (countdown)

Signups continue through Monday evening in the Pacific time zone (countdown to signups closing).

We've passed 50 people signed up, and I'm so excited to be doodling with everyone! I can't wait to see who signs up over the weekend! <3

Small update / Ongoing tag situation

Some fandoms seem to be extremely cursed, and cause me to get a 500 time out whenever I try to approve them.

If your fandom appears to be rejected, or it doesn't appear to be in the place it should be, I may have had to reject the fandom you nominated and slap a DFE or "Disambiguated For Exchanges" on it to make the tag nominations go through.

So far, the only affected fandom has been Buffy The Vampire Slayer. If this happens to your nominations, you can find the fandom under the Uncategorized Fandoms tab of the tagset. I apologize for the inconvenience!

If you have any questions about nominations, you can ask them here!

Nominations Query 2

Tagset approvals are humming along! I'm currently caught up with processing nominations as of 10 minutes ago, and we've a little more than a day and a half left before nominations close on Saturday, October 25th @ 10:00pm PDT (countdown)!

This post is providing information on a few of the nominations that have been made. Tags get rejected prior to querying just so that new tags can be displayed. If a tag has been rejected to be queried, don't panic! I will add any tags that you need back into the tagset manually.

Tags to Query

Original Work
Robot/Human having sex (OW)
Robots or Androids engaged in Wire Play (OW)

I'm allowing prompt-like tags through for Creator's Choice of Doodles, where you can get pretty specific about what you'd like to see--either as a specific art remix, or characters engaged in a specific activity. But for original work, we're sticking with ship formatting that doesn't lock anyone into having to draw any specific activity (even if an activity is highly implied by the tag).

For example, an accepted tag:

  • Squid Who Goes On An Adventure (OW) highly implies the activity the squid is going to do is "adventure", but the tag itself remains open to be interpreted by a creator in a variety of ways, pre-, during, or post-adventure (or even just thinking about things related to adventuring).

If you'd like to create more specific tags for Robot/Human, Robot/Robot, Robot/Android, or Android/Android, you will need to rephrase the tag(s) into something that would be accepted into the tagset. You will need to use your optional details to specify that you'd like to receive an M or E-rated fill and/or that you're interested in doodles about wireplay.

If you need help reformulating your tags, you can take a look at original works tags that have already been accepted into the tagset. If you'd like help workshopping OW tags that will be accepted into the tagset, you can contact me on this post or through the screened mod contact post.



Tags have been resubmitted and have been accepted into the tagset!

Signups Open!

Signups are now open for Doodle 4 Doodle! Signups close October 27th at 10:00 PM PDT (countdown). Nominations will remain open through October 25th!

Sign Up on AO3

Sign up here: Signup form

Browse requests here: Signup summary | Request summary | Tagset | AO3 app

Please read the rules before you sign up. To quickly sum up:

    Requests

  • You can request a minimum of 1 fandom, and a maximum of 10.
  • You can request 1-20 tags per fandom.
  • You can repeat fandom requests.
  • You can sign up with one fandom, but you must request 3+ different fandoms to be guaranteed a gift.

  • Offers

  • You can offer to create for 1-10 fandoms, with 1-20 characters/ships per fandom.
  • Doodle 4 Doodle uses OR matching. This means you will match to ONE tag.
  • If you are unmatchable when signups close (e.g. you are offering tags that no one else is requesting), you will be matched at random to someone requesting a Creator's Choice of Doodle tag.

  • Nominations Are Still Open!

  • If you're signing up and realize you forgot to nominate any fandoms, or characters/ships/objects/places (etc), you can mosey on over to the tagset!
  • I will be approving nominations several times per day until nominations close.
  • Nominations close ~48 hours before signups close (countdown to nominations close).
  • If you've nominated anything in the past day or two that is not visible in the tagset, check to see if it's been queried in a recent nomination clarification post. If it hasn't, please post here and let me know.

Since nominations and signups will are open concurrently, if you see any duplicate or migrating tags in your fandoms, comment here ASAP if you notice any issues. Once a tag has been requested by someone, it can't be corrected in the tagset.

If you have any questions, concerns, or comments, please comment here, drop me a comment on the screened mod contact post, or email me at outstandingfroggie2 at proton dot me.

Good luck, and I hope you will join us for D4D this round!!


Nominations Query 1

Nominations have been open for a day, and approvals are all caught up (up to the writing of this post). The tagset is looking tremendous so far!!

This post is seeking information on a few of the nominations that have been made. Tags get rejected prior to querying just so that new tags can be displayed. If a tag has been rejected to be queried, don't panic! I will add any tags that you need back into the tagset manually.


Tags to Query

My Little Pony Generation 1
Creator's choice of character as a pony
  • Nominator of MLPG1, could you confirm whether you want any character in MLP Generation 1 to be a pony, or if you want this tag to apply to any character in any fandom?

    If it's the latter, would you prefer that tag to be in Crossover Fandom, or Creator's Choice of Doodle fandom? I'll add whichever tag you want to the tagset. If you'd like more than one, please respond to this post to let me know!

  • "Creator's choice of character from any fandom drawn as a pony (My Little Pony G1)" added to tagset


Recipient's OCs for Doodles
Recipient’s Original Anthro/Furry Character (Recipient’s OCs)
  • Tag nominator, unfortunately the slash is ambiguous in this context (e.g. someone might want to use this as a relationship nomination, and then it would also need a "Group:" prefix). Would it be okay to rephrase this tag as "Recipient’s Original Anthro or Furry Character (Recipient’s OCs)"? Please respond to this post to let me know!

    updated tag has been added to the tagset!

If you've had a tag that's been rejected and it isn't noted in this post, please reach out here or on the screened mod contact post!


Entry tags:

Nominations are open!

Welcome to the inaugural round of Doodle for Doodle! Nominations are now open! The tagset can be viewed here and you can submit your nominations here.

Please read the nomination rules below before you nominate!

Eligible Fandoms

  • All fictional work fandoms, characters, and ships are eligible for this exchange.
  • Settings and objects from your fandoms are eligible.
  • Recursive nominations are eligible. See the FAQ for more information!
  • Specific or Pre-existing OCs can be nominated under the fandom "Recipient's OCs for Doodles". See more here.
  • Original Work and Creator's Choice of Doodle are eligible for the exchange.
  • RPF of famous people over the age of 18 are eligible for this exchange. There are some restrictions on RPF nominations. See Other Considerations in the rules for these restrictions.

Nominations Rundown

  • Each participant can nominate up to 10 fandoms, with up to 20 characters/ships in each fandom.
  • Nominations will be done in the character field.
  • You will be required to use a Group: prefix for any / or & relationships that involve more than one character
  • Settings or objects should use the Setting: or Object: prefix. If there is a canonical character tag for a setting or object, you may use that instead.
  • You may nominate Creator's Choice tags using the fandom Creator's Choice of Doodle, or under a specific fandom.
  • All nominations should be disambiguated.
  • See the nominations section of the rules for specific guidance on how to format nominations for Original Work, Crossovers, Recipient's OCs for Doodles, and more.
  • If you think there may be confusion about a tag you're planning to nominate, feel free to ask or give a heads up about it first. This lessens the chance of your nomination getting held up for a clarification post, or potentially rejected.

Frequently Asked Questions


Why do I have to use a Group: prefix for my relationship nominations? )
What is a disambiguation, and why should I do it? )
Help! I need more nomination slots! )
I'd like to receive a doodle for one of the works I have posted on AO3. How do I nominate that? )
I'd like to nominate a recursive fandom. Are there any extra steps? )

Please comment here, on the screened mod contact post or email the mod account if there are any questions or concerns about your nominations!


Screened Mod Contact Post

This is a screened post so that anyone who prefers to use DW can ask a question here instead of sending an email.

Please make sure to comment from a logged in account, or provide an email address where the mod can reply! Since all comments are screened, if you comment anonymously you won't be able to see your comment or the mod answer.

What you can post here:

  • Anything you'd like to post/ask privately
    • General questions about the exchange/rules
    • Do Not Match requests
    • Questions about your assignment or a PH
    • Questions you wish to be passed to a recipient
    • Short Extension requests (make sure to include your AO3 name)
    • Requests for summaries of your open assignments/PHs
    • Requests/fandoms you'd like to add to your PH if its after the assignments due deadline (November 30) and you have under three fandoms required to be guaranteed a gift

What you should include:

  • All replies to this post are screened. If you'd like to be able to see responses to your questions/requests on DW, please post logged in!
    • Your AO3 username (if relevant)
    • Your email address (if you don't have a DW)
    • Your question, request, or fandoms expansion.
    • If asking a question about an assignment or treat, the AO3 name of your recipient or intended recipient.
    • If sending in a Do Not Match request, please let us know the AO3 username(s) you do not want to match to.
    • If you are a PH and would like to expand your requests, please copy/paste the information in box below, and fill in your details!

Doodle 4 Doodle: Important Differences from MFD

Hello, and welcome to Doodle 4 Doodle! You may already be familiar with Multifandom Doodle; and you may have already noticed that many of this event's rules are similar to MFD. Here are some key differences:

  • More compressed schedule. D4D runs on a slightly compressed schedule, with overlapping nominations & signups.
  • Smaller minimum size for artwork. D4D's art minimum is 400x400 pixels. Mods are experimenting with this smaller minimum size that may be more friendly to pixel artists and people drawing emoji.
  • Different rules about 3D art eligibility. 3D artwork includes voxel art, art drawn with Blender's grease pencil, and CGI renders.
    • Art drawn with the Blender grease pencil is eligible to fulfill assignments.
    • Voxel art and CGI renders are welcome to fulfill assignments as long as they have some additional element of drawing or painting.
    • Voxel art and CGI renders with no element of drawing or painting is eligible to be given as treats.
  • Creator's Choice of Doodle is the name for the creator chooses fandom. You can request or offer a wide variety of things that you want to leave up to your creator.
  • Different rules about requesting already-exisiting OCs. We are experimenting with organizing these requests under a fandom heading of "Recipient's OCs" (if a recipient is requesting their own OCs) or under "Creator's Choice of Doodle" (if a recipient is requesting their creator to showcase the creator's own OCs). Read more about these nomination rules here.
  • One fandom minimum for requests/offers. Gifts are guaranteed for everyone who requests 3+ different fandoms!
  • Defaulting using the default button has no penalty in this exchange. If you get an assignment that doesn't suit you, please feel free to default and pick up an assignment you like better from the pinch hit list!
    • Defaulters still get gifts. All participants will be guaranteed a gift so long as they have 3+ different fandoms in their requests. This includes participants who have defaulted.
    • If you no-show default, you will not be able to sign up to the next round. Please use the default button or contact us through the screened mod post to default!

Doodle 4 Doodle: Schedule

Doodle4Doodle runs using a lightly compressed schedule, with nominations and signups open concurrently, and a four week creation period for artists. Extra time has been provided after assignments are due for extensions, editing your work, and pinch hits.

    Nominations open: October 17, 2025
    Nominations continue & Signups open: October 19
    Nominations close: October 25 (countdown)
    Signups close: October 27 (countdown)
    Assignments out: no later than October 30 assignments sent October 28!
    Assignments due: November 30 (countdown)
    Works revealed: December 12
    Creators revealed: December 19
    Please note: deadlines are 10:00pm PDT, until the end of daylight savings time, at which time deadlines switch to 10:00pm PST.